Resolved Bert1009 just trying to ruin or diminish my ability to sell with fake feedback

1. Date Dispute Happened
5/19/20

2. Are You The Buyer or Seller
I'm the Seller

3. Total Transaction Value
$0 USD

4. Other Parties Username
Bert1009

5. Method Used To Pay or Receive Payment
Offer made only, never accepted, no info exchanged

6. Other Parties Email Addresses
It does't say

7. Other Parties Payment Email Address
It doesn't say

8. Other Parties Messenger Username
N/A

9. Provide All Chat Logs and Additional Information Below

Here is offer 1 and how it unfolded.

1. Bert1009 has offered $ 30 for your
   Lvl 195 Account currently in wave3 region, #1 faction, region open for transfer. WHALE ACCOUNT!!!!! account using PlayerUp Middleman services, do you accept? Yes OR No
   
   Bert1009, 5/19/20Report
   Reply
   
   
2. 
   MichaelUltimo doesn't accept your offer of $30 for this listing. You can either buy now the current price or make another offer.
   
   MichaelUltimo, 5/20/20Report
   Reply
   
   
3. 
   bring that up only $570 and its all yopurs!
   
   MichaelUltimo, 5/20/20Report
   Reply
   
   
4. 
   or make a respectable offer.... $30 i would get more joy out of depot'ing the roster

Then offer 2 came in as follows,

1. Bert1009 has offered $ 60 for your
   Lvl 195 Account currently in wave3 region, #1 faction, region open for transfer. WHALE ACCOUNT!!!!! account using PlayerUp Middleman services, do you accept? Yes OR No
   
   Bert1009, 5/20/20Report
   Reply
   
   
2. 
   MichaelUltimo doesn't accept your offer of $60 for this listing. You can either buy now the current price or make another offer.
   
   MichaelUltimo, 5/20/20Report
   Reply
   
   
3. 
   This account is worth more than the $800.00USD my friend earned for his a month ago. I have DOUBLE everything he had and therefore am being EXTREMELY generous at my current asking price.
   I will not be accepting offers lower than $500.00USD UNLESS your also offering something physical for trade such as a PS4 console or something along those lines.
   Not trading for other accounts either.
   Any interesting physical trades such as consoles, collectibles, etc. + money OR above $500.00USD.
   Now that I have specified the minimum acceptable offers, anything offered less than the above outline will be considered an insult and earn a block.

After that final exchange he gave me this review,

1. Confirmed Completed Transaction
   • Trader
   • Bert1009 (-1)
   • 5/19/20

1. BERT1009
   5/19/20
   The following user completed a successful middleman transaction. If this feedback has been issued by user @Middleman then this is a valid feedback.
   He will not live up to his word swipe your money from under your nose. Will give you fake login information. I have played with this player in Greenville and Lewis. He cannot be trusted. Showing different pictures of someone else's team. He's only a s10
2. MICHAELULTIMO
   5/25/20
   Never been to Lewis before so clearly this guy is just upset that i would not accept his 20$ and 60$ offer. I am more than happy to make videos or pictures of my current roster...whatever it takes to prove this person is just a sour sore loser.
   After stating my minimum offers that I will accept i told this person I would block them if they continued making insulting offers and if it is who i suspect it is, has been a troll online since the very beginning. He is upset that I am able to achieve such an amazing account f2w while he is not even half as good as p2w.
   Even made a fake complaint, we never completed any transaction so will be reporting this to middleman and they will not only remove this fake negative but will block the user as well.
   Love you PlayerUp!

Now you have the story from the start to the finish! Do not let trolls and harassment prevail and get rid of him and the fake feedback. Would also be nice to justify the final line of "Love you" haha.

 

@Bert1009 user is disputing your feedback

 

No, did you read the conversation thread in my initial dispute form?
I posted the entire conversation back and forth where he clearly states his reason for the negative feedback as such,

"BERT1009
5/19/20
The following user completed a successful middleman transaction. If this feedback has been issued by user @Middleman then this is a valid feedback.
He will not live up to his word swipe your money from under your nose. Will give you fake login information. I have played with this player in Greenville and Lewis. He cannot be trusted. Showing different pictures of someone else's team. He's only a s10"



I am stipulating the fact that everything he claims is an outright lie which can also be confirmed through the same trail of threads and responses.
If i need to break it down for you sentence by sentence here it is,


1....."The following user completed a successful middleman transaction. If this feedback has been issued by user @Middleman then this is a valid feedback."
^^^^^We NEVER completed any transaction ever! There is stipulation and fake feedback reason 1.


2....."He will not live up to his word swipe your money from under your nose. Will give you fake login information."
^^^^^I have never given any login information out to any interested buyer yet at all, and no money ever exchanged between anyone either which you can also confirm through my account SO There is stipulation with fake feedback reason #2.


3....."I have played with this player in Greenville and Lewis. He cannot be trusted."
^^^^^Well besides the point of our personal relationship and the fact that I have never even been to Lewis so this guy has me confused with another Mike (very common name) the real problem with this sentence is he claims i cant be trusted????? WHY cant i be trusted, i have been completely transparent with every interested buyer ANNND reported multiple scammers to help other sellers....how can someone not be trusted when they are actively squashing scammers?
There is stipulation of fake feedback reason #3.


4....."Showing different pictures of someone else's team. He's only a s10"
^^^^^Lastly and certainly not least, this comment is also an outright lie for the same reasons above. You can look into all conversations i have ever had, and simply the reason that keep updating my postings rather consistently and you can even watch through the image trail the growth and rarely changing roster of pictures, this is my account! Somewhat circumstantial but no less likely to be the truth. Heck, you can request any image of my account right now and I will be more than happy to confirm any inquiries without delay.
Stipulation to fake feedback reason #4.


It is absolutely absurd that one person can make so many false claims within one paragraph and not only be allowed to continue to maintain his account on your site but who knows how many interested buyers looked at my post, saw his feedback and simply didn't want take a "risk" that never existed.
Look at the bottom of my posting thread too where i state refusal to accept any payments off site or outside of middleman services.
Clearly i am only here to sell my account through your services legitimately and stop the trolls and scammers of the world from getting the better of the innocent.
DO NOT LET HIM WIN! Squash this troll like the insect he is!

 

Having read your question a second time,
it is not HE who is disputing MY feedback...instead it is ME disputing HIS feedback for being an outright lie and fake!

 

Sooooooo..........?????

 

Feedback removed.

 

I appreciate that, however, there is still a -1 on my account. The only thing that was removed was his comments but not the negative score...the negative score still remaining will still have an impact on my ability to sell.

 

Months later that -1 still exists...you guys either are unable to remove this or just trollin'.

 

This will be resolved shortly.

 

Thanks if you do that!
If you look at all correspondence between me and any players you will see me consistently refusing all off-site communications/purchasing of my account. You will also see me crush several scammers in the past. As honest as I am and as true as I stick to the buyer/seller protections, the least I can expect is a pristine selling record/feedback.

 

"Resolved shortly" was 6 days ago